Neil & Otto's Pizza

Neil & Otto's Menu

 

Our Famous Pizza

Neil & Otto’s Pizza is made with our famous sauce blanketed with your choice of fresh ingredients and Vermont mozzarella atop our made-from-scratch-daily pizza dough.

 

Thin Crust or Thick Crust

These are our original crusts, and they are both the same price.

  10” 12” 16” 18”
  personal med.  lrg. x-lrg
cheese 6.49 8.49 11.49 12.49
Each Enhancement 0.99 1.29 1.99 2.29

Hand-Braided Deep Dish

This is our pizza atop a slightly thicker crust, bordered by our unique hand-braid.

  10” 12” 16” 18”
  personal med.  lrg. x-lrg
cheese 7.49 9.49 12.49 n/a
Each Enhancement 1.49 1.99 2.49 n/a

 

The Amazing Double Decker

This pizza actually has 2 layers of crust, sauce, toppings, and cheese. It takes us a little longer to prepare, but it is well worth the wait!

  10” 12” 16” 18”
  personal med.  lrg. x-lrg
cheese 8.49 12.49 17.49 n/a
Each Enhancement 1.49 1.99 2.49 n/a

 

Combo Pizzas

                                personal                 med.                        lrg.                          x-lrg.

Very Veggie: mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and black olives

                                9.49                         12.49                       17.49                       19.49

Cellar Special: pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and black olives

                                11.49                         14.49                       19.49                       21.49

Mighty Meaty: pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon

                                9.49                         12.49                       17.49                       19.49

Maui Waui: ham and pineapple

                                7.49                        10.49                         13.49                       15.49

 

Gourmet Pizzas

BBQ Chicken: BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, and fresh onions

                                9.49                         12.49                       17.49                       19.49

Mexicali Blues: salsa, seasoned ground beef, mozzarella, black olives, lettuce, and diced tomatoes

                                10.49                         13.49                       18.49                       20.49

Fresh Tomato: sliced tomatoes, garlic, and sweet basil on an olive oil brushed crust

                                8.49                         11.49                         15.49                       17.49

Savory Spinach: spinach, tomatoes, and feta cheese

                                8.49                         11.49                       15.49                       17.49

Chicken Licken: chicken, garlic, and tomatoes:

                                8.49                         11.49                       15.49                       17.49

Buffalo Chicken: Buffalo style chicken & a side of ranch or blue cheese

                                7.49                          10.49                        13.49                       15.49

Broccoli Chicken Alfredo: Broccoli & chicken atop Alfredo sauce instead of pizza sauce

                                8.49                         11.49                       15.49                       17.49

 

Enhancements

anchovies                              jalapenos                               pepperoni

bacon                                     ham                                         pineapple

black olives                           meatballs                               sausage

onions                                    mushrooms                           tomatoes

spinach                                  broccoli                                  ground beef

green peppers                       feta cheese                            chicken

garlic                                      cheddar cheese

 

Pizza of the People

The Rutherford:three cheese—parmesan, cheddar, and mozzarella

                                8.49                         11.49                       15.49                       17.49

G-Man: sausage, crushed red peppers, onions, and extra cheese

                                8.49                         11.49                       15.49                       17.49

Phat Needham: BBQ sauce, garlic, pineapple, and chicken

                                9.49                         12.49                       17.49                       19.49

Sweet Mama Johnson: our crust brushed with: our crust brushed with olive oil and topped with garlic, broccoli, mushrooms, and chicken

                                9.49                         12.49                       17.49                       19.49

The Galleygirl: pepperoni, tomatoes, mozzarella, cheddar, and parmesan

                                9.49                         12.49                       17.49                       19.49

Glenn Source: pepperoni and pineapple

                                7.49                         10.49                         13.49                       15.49

 

Calzones

cheese                                                                    6.49

each additional enhancement                            0.99

 

Pizza Styx

Stacy’s famous garlic spread topped with cheese—perfect for dipping in our signature sauce or ranch dressing!

small order (12’’ round)                                       7.99

large order (16” round)                                        9.99

 

Grinders

                                                6”                            12”

Turkey                                  3.99                         5.99

Ham                                        3.99                         5.99

Chicken Cutlet                    3.99                         5.99

Chicken Parm                     4.49                         6.49

Meatball                                4.49                         6.49

BBQ Chicken                      4.49                         6.49

All grinders include potato chips!

 

Scotty’s Famous Wraps

wrap choices: plain white, garlic herb, sun-dried tomato

Turkey                                                                  5.99

Ham                                                                        5.99

Chicken Cutlet                                                    5.99

Chicken Caesar: romaine lettuce, chicken, cheese, croutons, Caesar dressing

                                                                                5.99

Southwestern Chicken: chicken, olives, salsa, jack cheese, lettuce, jalapenos

                                                                                5.99

All wraps include potato chips!

 

Salads

                                                regular                    large

Garden                                   3.99                         4.99

Greek                                    4.49                         5.49

Chef’s                                    4.49                         5.49

Caesar                                   4.49                         5.49

Salad Dressings: Bleu cheese, Italian, Thousand Island, Caesar, French, Parmesan Pepper, Homemade Greek, Ranch, Honey Mustard

 

Appetizers

Buffalo Wings: hot, mild, or honey BBQ, ranch or bleu cheese dressing

                                                ½ order: 4.99         full order: 6.99

Garlic Bread                        regular: 1.49           large: 1.99

                                                w/cheese: 1.99      w/ cheese: 2.99

Three Cheese Bread: parmesan, mozzarella, cheddar

                                                                                3.99

Pizza Bread                          regular: 2.49           large: 3.99

Battered Mac & Cheese Wedges                    3.49

Extra Sauce or Dressing:                                  0.59

 

Beverages

Orangina Bottles                                                1.49

Yoo-hoo Bottles                                                   1.49

Minute Maid Juices                                            1.49

Powerade –    20 oz bottle                                 1.49

Coffee                                                                      .99

Soda –    20 oz bottle                                           1.49

                2 liter bottle                                           1.99

                fountain soda                                       1.19

                fountain pitcher—free refills!             2.49

Bottled water                                                        1.49

Desserts

Brownies                                                              1.99

Oreo Cheesecake Pies                                      1.99